Hello dear
Welcome To Papa D's Original
Papa D's Original, located in Tuckerton, NJ, is a cherished gem for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine. Renowned for its hearty offerings, the menu features standout dishes like the Tony Bennett Meatloaf and the Godfather Cheesesteak, both bursting with flavor and crafted with love. Freshly made breads and ingredients elevate every bite, showcasing traditional recipes reminiscent of family gatherings. The welcoming staff enhances the experience, making you feel right at home. With rave reviews highlighting the deliciousness and warmth, Papa D's promises not just a meal, but a heartfelt dining experience that transports you back to cherished Sunday dinners.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Tony Bennett
Mushrooms
Garlic Parmesan Green Beans
Sweet Potato Casserole
About
Papa D's Original
Welcome to my latest culinary discovery, Papa D's Original, located in the heart of Tuckerton, NJ. Nestled at 224 W Main St, this gem serves up heartwarming, home-style Italian food that feels like a warm embrace from your grandmother.
Papa D's is not just a restaurant; it's a celebration of authentic Italian cuisine that brings together flavorful dishes crafted with love. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted by a friendly staff, ready to guide you through a menu filled with delightful options. You can almost taste the nostalgia in their food, as customers rave about the sumptuous rice balls and divine vodka sauce that evoke memories of Sunday dinners at Nonna’s house.
If you are a fan of comforting layers of flavor, you’ll want to try their chicken parm, generously covered in luscious vodka sauce. The sides are equally captivating. Grab a pint of Pasta Salad, or indulge in their soft, homemade fries. Don’t miss out on the meatballs, which some reviewers say can transport you back to childhood like a scene from Ratatouille.
For those with a sweet tooth, the homemade tiramisu is a must-try. Customers have declared it "divine," hitting all the right spot for a perfect ending to your meal. Ample choices of add-ons—from fresh mozzarella to roasted peppers—allow you to personalize your plate just the way you like it.
Of course, the warm and welcoming service sets Papa D's apart. It's the kind of place where you can expect a smile with your order, and perhaps a friendly suggestion if you're undecided about what to choose. You’ll soon see that the food style here shuns pretentiousness in favor of pure joy and comfort.
Whether you're seeking a cozy dinner spot or quality takeout, Papa D's Original promises to deliver each time. With its unbeatable prices and heartwarming dishes, it's no wonder customers are eager to return time and again. As one satisfied patron said, "If you've never been, you need to go." Don't wait—visit today and experience the love that goes into every meal!
For inquiries or to place an order, call +1 609-722-1411. Treat yourself to an Italian feast at Papa D's, where every bite feels like home.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The food was delicious! My husband and I tried the rice balls, the chicken parm with vodka sauce and the zeppole. The bread is delicious and fresh from North Jersey. I would definitely suggest trying these. We’re so excited to come back and try more items on the menu. The service was also excellent and a very friendly woman helped us. Definitely give this place a try! ”
“ When you start with the most welcoming service around and end with the most delicious food you’ve ever had since Nona’s house at Sunday dinner; You’ve found Papa D’s. Nobody does “food made with love” better than them. Everything is fantastic. Rice balls? Amazing. Tiramisu? DIVINE. Vodka sauce? None better. The meatballs transported me back to my childhood like the critic in Ratatouille. Hands down, if you’ve never been, you need to go. ”
“ A true mom-and-pop gem serving delicious, home-style Italian food with heart. The staff is incredibly warm and generous—always ready with a smile and a sample. Great prices. Best for take out, but a few seats if you would like to enjoy your food there. ”
“ So we had lunch from there today ! It was amazing! Super flavorful, soft bread , fresh food . We had the specials ( 3 different hoagies ) chicken Marsala with spinach and provolone, was great! Eggplant parm was top notch , and the rib eye with peppers and onions, with a glaze .. was a huge hit ! Thank you ”
“ The food is absolutely amazing. And Marybeths vodka sauce is to die for. I recommend this place to everyone and plan to be a constant visitor. Food was completely out of this world ”
“ My 1st time here and it was WONDERFUL!! I just wanted a small sampling of different items for a weekend of no cooking for myself and they were so accommodating. Everything tastes just like homemade home cooked Italian food. Chicken cutlets were cooked to perfection, and meatballs are large and tender, sausage was melt in your mouth with wonderful sauce. The RICE BALL was huge and you gotta have the vodka sauce!! I got a sesame sandwich roll for dipping..so good. I'm definitely returning for that rice ball and chicken cutlets. They are such lovely people who treated me like family I didn't know I had. So if you're in Tuckerton on Rt 9, you MUST stop in! P.S. It's cash only and they have an ATM outside if you need it. There's ample parking and a little outside dining area too. I have mobility issues and they carried my order to my car and it was very much appreciated!! ”
“ 1st time visiting and was immediately welcomed and offered a sample of their rice ball. I cannot believe I've driven by so many times. Delicious sandwiches and fresh made fries. Had fresh mozzarella cheese and cookies on the counter for sale. We will be back. Cash only ”
“ Wow. Phenomenal Service And Food! I got a sample of the rice ball with the vodka sauce and it's out of this world! I also ordered a cheesesteak and that was great as well. This place feels like you're right at home. If i'm ever in this area again, i'll make sure to come back. ”